법원에 올리는 상소문
Beginning and finishing without a plumbing permit is acceptable.
However, other traders said the entire pipe replacement job should have required a permit. Even if he could do it without a license, shouldn't he have done it correctly? The problem is that many things he did were not up to code, and some were installed incorrectly. I never heard of a company named Green Tech. I heard he worked for the Surrey School Board and could work at my house because school was still in session. Some workers he brought said they were certified plumbers, so I thought they would do it well.
I was very grateful that they finished the job in one day. That day, Jagdish left the house without cleaning after themselves but took all the copper pipes from our home. I found out later that they were sold at a high price.
He asked me to point out all their mistakes. I am not a plumber. I hired him to do the work correctly and paid him $8900. Mr. Sunar asked me to find their mistakes so he could fix them. I overheard James point out the back sloping of the drain, and Mr. Sunar's nephew tried to cover it up by saying it was okay because they used a 2" pipe instead of 1 1/2". What an absurd nonsense!
Of course, he returned and fixed some of it, but there were still problems. In fact, on the day he visited to fix it, he left without saying anything and didn't fix it all. Jack said he didn't do anything wrong, but many traders who visited the site, including professional plumbers, can attest to how bad the sewer and water pipes Jack installed were. Jack himself would admit that he fixed the ones he installed on the first day based on the advice of other experts.
electrical and furnace replacement inspection
I heard that if another inspector came and found out that our plumbing work was being done without a permit, all other work could be stopped. That was a massive shock to me since the construction was already delayed. Ultimately, I wanted to hire other plumbers to finish the work. They said they got the permit quickly and started working.
It was suitable to apply for a permit, even if it was late, so they applied for a license as if they were fixing work someone else had already done.
, remove all of Jack's installations that were not up to code,
The problem with their work was that they didn't just replace everything as is; they
You could tell at a glance that their work and Jack's were different. They did other things besides replacing the pipes, so it’s hard to compare the exact amounts, but their invoices for the neatly completed work were less than Jack had requested. How can I say that the delays caused by Jack and the fact that I had to do the same work twice were not my fault? How can he tell his job?
He was part of the company when I paid him in cash to make it convenient for him to work outside.
He must also have been trying to avoid reporting taxes. This happened after Jack came to my house to do the work.
Your Honour,
My name is, and I am the claimant in this case.
I respectfully disagree with Mr. Jagdish Sunar's reply, as it contains several inaccuracies and misrepresentations.
1. Permitting Issues
- Mr. Sunar claimed that completing the plumbing work without a permit was acceptable.
- However, other tradespeople informed me that the entire pipe replacement job should have required a permit.
- The work conducted by Mr. Sunar was not up to code, and some installations were incorrect.
2. Misrepresentation and Poor Quality of Work
- I was unaware of a company named "Green Tech," which Mr. Sunar claimed to represent. I thought that the Surrey School Board employed him and that he could Honour,
My name is Youngsun Cho, and I stand before you as the claimant in this case, seeking justice regarding my experience with Mr. Jagdish Sunar.
I must respectfully refute Mr. Sunar's reply, which is riddled with inaccuracies and misrepresentations regarding the plumbing work performed at my home.
**1. Permitting Issues**
Mr. Sunar asserts that completing the plumbing work without a permit was acceptable. However, I have since learned from various tradespeople that the pipe replacement job unequivocally required proper permitting. While Mr. Sunar may believe otherwise, adherence to local regulations is not merely a suggestion but a necessity to ensure safety and compliance.
**2. Quality of Work**
Unfortunately, the quality of work executed by Mr. Sunar and his team was far from satisfactory. Many aspects of the installation failed to meet building codes, and some components were installed incorrectly. This is not just a minor oversight; it directly jeopardizes the safety and functionality of my home's plumbing system. I expected professionalism and expertise, yet I received a hasty job riddled with mistakes instead.
**3. Issues with Conduct**
On the day of completion, while I was grateful that the job was finished in a single day, I was dismayed to find that Mr. Sunar left my home in disarray, neglecting to clean up after the work and taking all the copper pipes that belonged to me. I later discovered that these pipes had been sold for a significant profit. Such actions raise serious concerns about ethics and professionalism.
**4. Lack of Responsibility**
When I pointed out the numerous problems to Mr. Sunar, he suggested I identify and list the mistakes for him. As a homeowner, I am not a plumbing expert; I hired him to provide a professional service for which I paid $8,900. My responsibility was not to correct his work; I relied on his expertise to ensure everything was done correctly.
**5. Incomplete Repairs**
Although Mr. Sunar returned multiple times to address issues, his solutions were often incomplete. I have records indicating that he indicated he would fix problems, yet upon his departure, numerous faults remained. His reluctance to obtain the necessary permit further exacerbates the situation. Our entire project remains in jeopardy without a license—an alarming prospect given the potential consequences of non-compliance.
**6. Costs Incurred**
To add insult to injury, the costs I have incurred due to Mr. Sunar’s inadequate work continue to mount. After learning of the extensive issues and the necessity for a proper permit, I was compelled to hire licensed plumbers to redo the job. Their invoices for the neatly completed solutions were notably less than what Mr. Sunar charged, raising questions about the value and integrity of his services.
In light of these points, I implore you to recognize the discrepancies in Mr. Sunar's statements and the profound impact his actions have had on my home and finances. I seek the appropriate remedy for my incurred damages and believe Mr. Sunar must be held accountable for his shortcomings.
Thank you for your attention to this matter. I trust you will consider my case carefully.
Sincerely,
Youngsun Cho worked at my house because school was still in session. - The workers Mr. Sunar brought claimed to be certified plumbers, which led me to believe they would perform the work to a professional standard.
- Although the job was completed in one day, Mr. Sunar and his team left without cleaning up and took all the copper pipes from my home. I later discovered these pipes were sold at a high price.
3. Discovery of Issues
- A subsequent plumber who came to do another job identified numerous problems with the work done by Mr. Sunar and expressed disbelief at the quality.
- Mr. Sunar requested that I identify all the mistakes so he could fix them, even though I am not a professional plumber. I paid Mr. Sunar $8,900 in cash for the work to be done correctly.
- I overheard a tradesman named James pointing out the drain's backsloping. Mr. Sunar's nephew attempted to cover it up by claiming it was acceptable because they used a 2" pipe instead of the required 1 1/2". This is incorrect.
4. Multiple Visits and Incomplete Fixes
- Mr. Sunar returned several times to address the issues, but many problems persisted.
- On the day he visited to fix the problems, he left without addressing all the issues.
- Numerous tradespeople, including professional plumbers, can attest to the substandard quality of Mr. Sunar's work.
- Mr. Sunar admitted to fixing some of the issues based on advice from other experts.
5. Lack of Permits and Further Complications
- Mr. Sunar never obtained the necessary permits and insisted that I would have to pay if I wanted him to receive them.
- The price Mr. Sunar charged was higher than the estimates from other plumbers, which I initially accepted due to his confidence and quick completion promise. However, the quality of his work was unsatisfactory.
- I could not allow Mr. Sunar to continue working without a permit, which could have halted other scheduled inspections and construction work.
6. Hiring Other Plumbers
- I eventually hired other plumbers who applied for the necessary permits and began correcting Mr. Sunar's work.
- The new plumbers removed Mr. Sunar's installations that were not up to code and completed the work to a higher standard.
- Their invoices for the completed work were less than what Mr. Sunar charged despite them performing additional tasks.
Conclusion
- The delays and repeated work caused by Mr. Sunar were not my fault.
- Mr. Sunar must have been trying to avoid reporting taxes, as I paid him in cash for his convenience.
- This situation arose after Mr. Sunar's initial work at my house.
Your Honour,
My name is, and I stand before you as the claimant in this case, seeking justice regarding my experience with Mr. Jagdish Sunar.
I must respectfully refute Mr. Sunar's reply, which is riddled with inaccuracies and misrepresentations regarding the plumbing work performed at my home.
**1. Permitting Issues**
Mr. Sunar asserts that completing the plumbing work without a permit was acceptable. However, I have since learned from various tradespeople that the pipe replacement job unequivocally required proper permitting. While Mr. Sunar may believe otherwise, adherence to local regulations is not merely a suggestion but a necessity to ensure safety and compliance.
**2. Quality of Work**
Unfortunately, the quality of work executed by Mr. Sunar and his team was far from satisfactory. Many aspects of the installation failed to meet building codes, and some components were installed incorrectly. This is not just a minor oversight; it directly jeopardizes the safety and functionality of my home's plumbing system. I expected professionalism and expertise, yet I received a hasty job riddled with mistakes instead.
**3. Issues with Conduct**
On the day of completion, while I was grateful that the job was finished in a single day, I was dismayed to find that Mr. Sunar left my home in disarray, neglecting to clean up after the work and taking all the copper pipes that belonged to me. I after discovered that these pipes had been sold for a significant profit. Such actions raise serious concerns about ethics and professionalism.
**4. Lack of Responsibility**
When I pointed out the numerous problems to Mr. Sunar, he suggested I identify and list the mistakes for him. As a homeowner, I am not a plumbing expert; I hired him to provide a professional service for which I paid $8,900. My responsibility was not to correct his work; I relied on his expertise to ensure everything was done correctly.
**5. Incomplete Repairs**
Although Mr. Sunar returned multiple times to address issues, his solutions were often incomplete. I have records indicating that he indicated he would fix problems, yet upon his departure, numerous faults remained. His reluctance to obtain the necessary permit further exacerbates the situation. Our entire project remains in jeopardy without a license—an alarming prospect given the potential consequences of non-compliance.
**6. Costs Incurred**
To add insult to injury, the costs I have incurred due to Mr. Sunar’s inadequate work continue to mount. After learning of the extensive issues and the necessity for a proper permit, I was compelled to hire licensed plumbers to redo the job. Their invoices for the neatly completed solutions were notably less than what Mr. Sunar charged, raising questions about the value and integrity of his services.
In light of these points, I implore you to recognize the discrepancies in Mr. Sunar's statements and the profound impact his actions have had on my home and finances. I seek the appropriate remedy for my incurred damages and believe Mr. Sunar must be held accountable for his shortcomings.
Thank you for your attention to this matter. I trust you will consider my case carefully.
Sincerely,
존경하는 재판장님,
제 이름은 개똥이며, 저는 이 사건의 원고로서 이 자리에 서서 제 집에서 발생한 Mr. Jagdish Sunar와의 경험에 대해 공정한 판결을 구하고 있습니다.
Mr. Sunar의 답변에는 여러 가지 부정확성과 왜곡이 포함되어 있음을 존경하는 재판장님께 말씀드리고자 합니다.
1. 허가 문제 Mr. Sunar는 배관 작업을 허가 없이 완료하는 것이 적절하다고 주장했습니다. 그러나 여러 무역업자들로부터 파이프 교체 작업에는 적절한 허가가 필요하다는 것을 알게 되었습니다. Mr. Sunar가 생각하는 것과는 달리, 지역 규정을 준수하는 것은 단순한 권장사항이 아닌 안전과 규정을 준수하기 위한 필수 사항입니다.
2. 작업 품질 불행히도, Mr. Sunar와 그의 팀이 수행한 작업의 품질은 매우 실망스러웠습니다. 설치된 많은 부분이 건축 코드를 준수하지 않았고 일부 구성 요소는 잘못 설치되었습니다. 이는 단순한 실수가 아니라 제 집의 배관 시스템의 안전과 기능을 직접적으로 위협하는 중대한 문제입니다. 저는 전문성과 기술력을 기대했지만, 오히려 실수투성이의 급하게 마무리된 작업을 받았습니다.
3. 행동 문제 작업 완료 당일, 작업이 하루 만에 끝났다는 점은 감사했지만, Mr. Sunar가 집을 정리하지 않은 채 떠나고 제 집의 모든 구리 파이프를 가져갔다는 사실에 실망했습니다. 이후에 이 파이프들이 상당한 이익을 위해 판매되었다는 것을 알게 되었습니다. 이러한 행동은 윤리와 전문성에 대한 심각한 우려를 제기합니다.
4. 책임 부족 제가 Mr. Sunar에게 여러 문제를 지적했을 때, 그는 제가 실수를 식별하고 목록을 작성해달라고 요청했습니다. 저는 집주인이지 배관 전문가가 아닙니다; 저는 전문 서비스를 제공받기 위해 $8,900를 지불했습니다. 제 책임은 그의 작업을 수정하는 것이 아니라 모든 것이 제대로 완료되도록 그의 전문성에 의존하는 것이었습니다.
5. 불완전한 수리 Mr. Sunar는 여러 번 문제를 해결하기 위해 돌아왔지만, 그의 해결책은 종종 불완전했습니다. 그가 문제를 해결하겠다고 했음에도 불구하고 떠난 후에도 많은 결함이 남아 있었습니다. 허가를 받으려는 그의 꺼림칙한 태도는 상황을 더욱 악화시켰습니다. 허가 없이 전체 프로젝트가 위험에 처해 있었으며, 준수하지 않을 경우의 잠재적인 결과를 고려할 때 이는 매우 불안한 전망입니다.
6. 발생한 비용 설상가상으로, Mr. Sunar의 부적절한 작업으로 인해 발생한 비용이 계속 증가하고 있습니다. 광범위한 문제와 적절한 허가의 필요성을 알게 된 후, 저는 허가된 배관공을 고용하여 작업을 다시 하도록 강요받았습니다. 그들의 깔끔하게 완료된 작업에 대한 청구서는 Mr. Sunar가 청구한 금액보다 현저히 적었습니다. 이는 Mr. Sunar의 서비스 가치와 무결성에 대한 의문을 제기합니다.
이러한 점들을 감안하여, 저는 Mr. Sunar의 진술의 불일치를 인식하고 그의 행동이 제 집과 재정에 미친 심각한 영향을 고려해 주시길 바랍니다. 저는 발생한 손해에 대한 적절한 구제를 구하며, Mr. Sunar가 그의 부족함에 대해 책임을 져야 한다고 믿습니다.
이 문제에 대한 귀하의 관심에 감사드립니다. 제 사건을 신중히 고려해 주시길 바랍니다.
진심으로,
캐나다 법원에 올리는 상소문 글 받아 번역하고 정리해 다시 쓴뒤 한글로 바꿔올려보네요.